Facebook
X
Pinterest
Copy Link
You find a new home you like. The builder is advertising a huge incentive—maybe $10,000, $20,000, or even more toward closing costs or financing.
So you ask what seems like an obvious question:
“If you’re willing to give me $20,000, why not just take $20,000 off the price of the house?”
And the builder says no.
It can seem ridiculous at first. After all, $20,000 is $20,000, right?
Not necessarily.
Builders often have a strong financial reason to offer incentives rather than reduce a home’s sales price. A lower price can affect comparable sales, future appraisals, and the prices buyers expect to pay for other homes in the community. An incentive can make your purchase more attractive without lowering the recorded sales price.
More importantly, a $20,000 price reduction isn’t automatically a better deal for you, either.
Let’s look at why.
The Builder Is Thinking About More Than Your Home
An individual homeowner selling a house usually has one primary concern: getting that particular home sold.
A builder may be looking at things very differently.
The company could still have dozens—or even hundreds—of homes and homesites to sell in that community or surrounding communities.
Suppose several similar new homes have recently sold for around $500,000.
You come along and offer $480,000.
The builder might be perfectly capable of absorbing that $20,000 reduction on your particular house. But accepting it creates a $480,000 sale that may now become part of the market data for the neighborhood.
The next buyer might ask why an almost identical house sold for $480,000 while the builder is asking them to pay $500,000.
And that’s only the beginning of the problem.
Lower Prices Can Affect Future Appraisals
When a buyer finances a home, the lender will typically require an appraisal to help determine whether the property supports the amount being financed.
Appraisers don’t simply look at the builder’s asking price. They examine relevant recent sales and make adjustments for differences among properties.
In a newer community, some of the best comparable sales may be other homes recently sold by that same builder.
One discounted sale isn’t necessarily going to reset the value of an entire neighborhood. But if a builder begins reducing prices substantially across multiple homes, those lower sales can make maintaining higher prices more difficult.
That can eventually create appraisal problems on future transactions.
So instead of doing this:
Home price: $500,000
Negotiated price: $480,000
the builder may prefer:
Home price: $500,000
Builder incentive: $20,000
The buyer receives financial assistance, but the home’s contracted sales price remains $500,000.
Builders Also Want to Protect Their Pricing
There’s a psychological component to this as well.
Imagine you’re shopping in a new-home community and discover that someone bought your favorite floor plan last month for $25,000 less than the builder is asking you to pay.
What’s probably your next question?
“Why can’t I get that price?”
That’s precisely the conversation the builder may be trying to avoid.
Builders need to sell today’s house, but they also need to protect their ability to sell tomorrow’s house.
That’s one reason incentives can increase even when advertised home prices don’t move very much.
Why Do So Many Builder Incentives Require a Preferred Lender?
Here’s another piece buyers should understand.
That giant incentive advertised on the builder’s website may come with conditions.
One of the most common is:
You must use the builder’s preferred lender to receive the full incentive.
Large builders may have affiliated mortgage companies, joint ventures, or established lending relationships that help them create financing packages.
Depending on the promotion, builder incentive money might be used for things such as:
- Closing costs
- Discount points
- A permanent mortgage-rate buydown
- A temporary rate buydown
- Prepaid expenses
- Certain upgrades or options
- A combination of allowable expenses
That’s why you need to look beyond the headline.
A builder advertising “$20,000 in incentives!” isn’t necessarily offering to hand you a $20,000 check.
Find out exactly how the money can be used and what you must do to qualify for it.
Is $20,000 Off the Price Better Than $20,000 Toward Closing Costs?
This is where buyers should stop thinking about the builder for a moment and concentrate on themselves.
Let’s use the same $500,000 house.
If the builder reduces the purchase price to $480,000, you aren’t normally receiving $20,000 in cash. You’re buying the property for $20,000 less.
That’s certainly valuable.
But depending on your financing, the difference in your monthly mortgage payment may be smaller than you expect because that $20,000 is being spread across a long-term loan.
Now consider the alternative.
The builder keeps the price at $500,000 but allows $20,000 to be used toward eligible closing costs or to reduce your mortgage rate.
That could substantially reduce the cash you need at closing. If some of the money can be used for a permanent interest-rate buydown, it could also reduce your monthly mortgage payment.
Which is better?
There isn’t one answer that works for every buyer.
Make the Builder and Lender Show You the Numbers
This is one of the most useful things you can do when comparing new-home incentives.
Don’t simply ask:
“How much is the incentive?”
Ask what the transaction looks like under different scenarios.
For example, have the lender show you:
Scenario 1: Full purchase price with the maximum builder incentive.
Scenario 2: Lower purchase price with a reduced incentive.
Scenario 3: Full purchase price with incentive money used to permanently lower the mortgage rate.
Then compare:
- Cash needed at closing
- Interest rate and APR
- Monthly principal and interest
- Total estimated monthly payment
- Initial mortgage balance
- Cost of the rate buydown
- How long you expect to own the home
- What happens financially if you refinance or sell earlier than expected
Now you’re comparing actual dollars instead of marketing language.
A Big Incentive Isn’t Always a Great Deal
This deserves emphasis.
The biggest advertised incentive isn’t necessarily the best financial deal.
Suppose Builder A offers you $25,000 in incentives but its preferred lender has a higher rate or higher lender fees.
Builder B offers only $15,000 but has a more competitive overall financing package.
Which builder is offering the better deal?
You can’t answer that from the incentive number alone.
The same applies to upgrades. Twenty thousand dollars in design-center credit isn’t necessarily equivalent to $20,000 toward your cash-to-close needs.
You have to determine what the incentive is actually worth to you.
When Might the Lower Price Be Better?
There are situations where I’d certainly want to explore the price reduction.
Maybe you have plenty of cash available and don’t need much help with closing costs.
Perhaps you don’t expect to keep the mortgage long enough to benefit substantially from paying for a permanent rate reduction.
Or maybe your priority is simply beginning with the lowest possible purchase price and loan balance.
The important thing is not assuming that either choice is automatically better.
Compare them.
Inventory Homes Can Give Buyers More Negotiating Opportunities
The builder’s motivation can also change depending on the house you’re buying.
A to-be-built home that won’t be completed for months is one thing.
A completed inventory home that’s been sitting unsold is something else.
Completed homes can tie up the builder’s capital and carry ongoing expenses. Builders may also be trying to reach monthly, quarterly, community, or year-end sales goals.
That doesn’t guarantee they’ll reduce the price.
But it may create opportunities involving price, financing, closing costs, upgrades, appliances, lot premiums, or other concessions.
That’s why I encourage new-construction buyers to look at the whole deal, not simply the advertised base price.
Can You Negotiate With a Home Builder?
Yes.
But new-construction negotiations often work differently from negotiations with an individual homeowner.
Sometimes the builder won’t move on price but will move on financing.
Sometimes an inventory home has substantially more flexibility than a home that hasn’t been built yet.
Sometimes the opportunity is an upgrade, lot premium, appliance package, closing-cost contribution, or interest-rate incentive.
And sometimes the builder really isn’t willing to negotiate much at all.
The key is finding out where the flexibility actually exists.
Builder Incentives Change—Sometimes Quickly
One last thing buyers should know: today’s promotion isn’t necessarily next month’s promotion.
Builders adjust incentives based on inventory, interest rates, sales pace, construction schedules, remaining homesites, corporate objectives, and local market conditions.
The same builder may even offer different incentives at two communities only a few miles apart.
That’s why I wouldn’t choose a home simply because the advertisement has the biggest dollar amount attached to it.
First decide whether the home and community are right for you.
Then figure out how to structure the best available deal.
So Why Won’t the Builder Just Lower the Price?
Because from the builder’s perspective, $20,000 toward your closing costs and $20,000 off the sales price can have very different consequences.
Lowering the sales price can affect comparable sales, appraisals, future buyer expectations, and pricing on the builder’s remaining homes.
Offering an incentive can help the builder sell the home without necessarily creating the same downward pressure on neighborhood pricing.
But remember: protecting the builder’s pricing isn’t your job.
Your job is determining which available option gives you the greatest financial benefit.
Ask questions. Get the alternatives in writing. Compare the financing. Look at your cash to close and monthly payment.
And don’t be afraid to ask:
“What else can you do?”
Sometimes that’s where the interesting part of a new-construction negotiation begins.
For more information about buying a new construction home, NewHomeWeekly.com is another site of mine dedicated specifically to new homes and new-home buyers.
